Home > Musings > We, the people of Karnataka, want Development and not Charity!

We, the people of Karnataka, want Development and not Charity!

March 3, 2012

More than 110,000 families in Mysore district will be the recipients of the Government’s largesse today when the Chief Minister hands out various benefits of different schemes to them. This event has now been labeled Sarkari Savalattu Santhe. It is truly a market, wherein different products are being made available to people. The only difference is that you cannot get what you really want and need, but will have to take what a patronizing Government is willing to give.

I am not trying to make a point that many of the people receiving these much-needed benefits are undeserving of getting them. I am only trying to argue the case that the Government may not have truly understood the difference between political doles and true development. Every single party and political leader of the recent past has been guilty of indulging in such theatrics where thousands of crores of rupees worth of goods and services are distributed to ‘beneficiaries’. We have seen many such mega-events take place in different district headquarters, with either the Chief Minister himself or the district minister-in-charge personally ‘gifting’ away these Government benefits.

One can understand that it is the Government’s responsibility to ensure that the poorest of the poor do not lose out on the benefits of development. But one would like to be convinced that it is the poorest and the most deserving that are actually getting these benefits. We need to look at the ground realities. The state of Karnataka has 1.2 crore families and the Government has determined that 98 lakh families are living below the poverty line. It is indeed ironical that on one hand the Government touts the State as one of the most progressive in the country, but on the other hand has tacitly distributed BPL cards to nearly 80% of the population. We also need to keep in mind that 49% of the BPL card holders are not truly poor, while 5% of the real poor do not have a BPL card. In such a scenario, one can imagine whose benefit these schemes are truly serving.

If money spent on such ‘tamashas’ had truly benefited the poor, one wonders why we still have so much poverty around us. Every time a new Chief Minister takes over the Government, he is quick to have special packages for his native district. Thousands of crores of funds from the public exchequer is treated as their own personal funds and sanctioned to keep their constituents happy and satisfied. Most of the decision-making is done based on political realities, rather than on the development consequences that one wants to achieve.

Apart from treating our own citizens as mere recipients of their patronage, these events also snatch away people’s dignity and self-respect. How will our MLAs feel if they are made to stand in line and receive their I-pads and Laptops from a more than generous Government under full public and media glare? Our deserving poor cannot be made to feel like mere beneficiaries and given doles under such visibility and public gaze. They need the help of a Government machinery that understands their poverty and gently facilitates their social and economic mobility upwards towards self-reliance. Mahatma Gandhi always said that our poor had to be treated with the greatest respect and the State should never make a mockery of their poverty. What events like these do is exactly the opposite. In order to achieve narrow political gains, it makes the poor vulnerable and robs them of their dignity and self-respect. It also dis-empowers them and takes away the human spirit of enterprise.

What our Chief Minster and his cabinet colleagues have to ask themselves is whether their numerous development schemes are truly initiating and promoting the needed development? Is the return on investment proportional to the thousands of crores of rupees spent? Who is to ensure accountability in the system? Will the political or the bureaucratic executive take the responsibility of ensuring that this money will be well spent and every person receiving the benefits is truly deserving of the same and will join the economic mainstream? We have had numerous such events happen in the past and we as citizens of this State would like to know how much of poverty have they helped in alleviating. Instead of mere doles, shouldn’t the Government take a fresh look at its own budgetary allocations to the poor, the development of the scheduled castes & tribes and the marginalized?

It is also the Government’s responsibility to inform the citizenry who is paying for these mega events. Is it coming out of the public exchequer and if yes, under which head of account is it accounted for? If not, are the myriad contractors involved in the scheme paying for the same (as is the case generally)? We do have the right to know.

Unless the Government decides that its concern for development goes beyond petty politics and revolves around genuine social concern for the poor, and is willing to subject itself to measurement and accountability, good governance will continue to be a casualty. The State will only be helping its citizenry to merely cope with poverty instead of permanently climbing out of it. Is our political and bureaucratic executive willing to listen?


Categories: Musings
  1. Chandra Prakash.R
    March 4, 2012 at 9:05 am

    In India it is, to quote Shankkar Aiyar in The New Sunday Express, dt 4th march 2012, Jugaad Economics and Voodoo Politics. Just take the example of Slum Clearance. This is only encouraging more slums as the whole thing is mafia controlled. In a country where the percentage of tax payers to population is so low, and the government has better job to do in providing much needed infrastructure, how can govt spend money in wasteful but politically beneficial projects. Sarkari Savalathu Santhe is just another Jugaad Economics and Voodoo Politics.

  2. Arun Karpur
    March 3, 2012 at 11:10 pm

    Balu: You raise a critical and important issue of development. It appears that politicians have least to gain from sustainable development and mainstreaming of poor in contemporary economy. These are vote banks and their main aim of re-election gets satisfied by pleasing the constituents belonging to their village or their caste. It is not just sufficient to blame our political nuckle-heads. I think people who elect them to office must bear a greater responsibility by setting a set of accountability standards signaled in their response to re-election of these politicians. I also find fault within our cultural understanding of poverty and rulers’ response to poor (e.g., our mythological stories are full of such acts). Unfortunately we have known to appreciate the gesture of giving saris to poor women at public form and fall short of crying out loud against their lack of safety-net due to adverse life situations, including their safety and security. Accountability and use of public money at whims and fancies of politicians is actually a distant link that people are either unwilling or unable to make. Even our contemporary media does not do a good job in deciphering the societal damage of such doles and gimmicks. What India and its citizens need is a constant education on citizenship responsibilities and a deeper understanding of governance. Educating politicians will not work as they respond to their inner desires to hold on to power and they will do things that brings in best returns on investment on their personal ambitions – not necessarily to the society or nation. Empowering people with education that helps in re-setting the mind-set of people instilling values of good governance is the only way forward to stopping this non-sense and harmful drama of rolling out public benefits.

  3. muthu goudar
    March 3, 2012 at 11:06 am

    sir, nimma lekhana sarakarada gimicgala bagge kannu teresitu.

  1. No trackbacks yet.
Comments are closed.